I think you are putting pressure on yourself that doesn’t have to be there.
I think we all do it. But I will point it out if it helps.
It sounds to me like right now you have decided that staying married is what works for you.
I do not think it’s unfair that you do not have all the feels for him. I do think it’s a huge gift to him that you stay and let it evolve.
I think right now it’s just a hard place to be in. Being married is easier, yet you don’t have the same things to offer him or the marriage as you once did. This leads to a lot of feelings of discomfort. And guilt?
The best thing to do in my opinion is try and accept where you are completely. You did not cause this situation. It’s not your job to fix the situation. There is nothing wrong with being passive for a while, being authentic to yourself.
Life is a river, we go through lots of phases only to flow into other phases.
Change takes a long time. He very well may continue to grow into a man that you can and do respect again. And from that you may next see him with some appreciation and eventually that may lead back to love.
Or, you will get your kids raised a little further, and you will continue to grow away from him and eventually divorce.
I don’t think it’s odd you aren’t doing cartwheels about what he is doing right yet. It feels to me you have accepted the worst case scenario and are okay with it. There is nothing wrong with treading water until the tide changes and directs you in a different direction.
Are you feeling guilty towards him for doing so? Maybe unravel that if it’s what causes the pressure. He broke it, he seems committed to trying to fix it. It’s okay if you do not yet want to meet him with the same desire at this point. He made the mess, he can do the heavy lifting towards that. If or when the day comes you feel like matching his energy, then do that. If it doesn’t come, then there are answers in that too.
But for sure pressuring yourself is not going to make anything come faster. You are in this with eyes wide open which I think is unique on its own. I think if your eyes are wide open, your heart will be closed. But if those eyes witness what they really need to see, he has a chance in there. And that’s why you should not feel guilty. You are giving the chance, even if it’s with skepticism. I don’t know how someone could be cheated on and not feel skeptical of the person who did it. It’s all very natural, you just have to find a way to be okay and relax into it.
You will make a decision when it feels clearer. Dealing in unknowns is always the scariest part.