Hey positivemind, former BH here. Full disclosure, my first wife betrayed me with my then best friend. I stuck it out for ten extremely difficult years with a quasi-remoresful, constantly rugsweeping wife. I told myself that I would stay "for the kids" (we had young children and I did verify later that they were mine). I regret that decision to this day. That said, I have a bit of a different take.
I read your first post which you ended with:
"We are both here stuck wishing the other was different."
As this was not too long ago, I am assuming that not much has changed in the interim.
You also admitted that you have basically "friendzoned" each other with no real physical or much emotional intimacy. I relate to this as it was much the same with me and my first wife for a long time. We got along ok, especially in front of the kids, but never had true relational intimacy again with all that entails as spouses. Thankfully, I now have all of that and more with my current wife who is also a survivor of a brutal betrayal.
I dont think its about a pub, its location, or drinking with his buddies. I think its about deciding what you want for your life moving forward. Marital purgatory is a terrible way to live.
That said, let me ask you this:
• If he showed true lasting remorse,
• If he worked in himself consistently to be a safe partner,
• If he made time every day, every week to build communicational/relational intimacy, i.e., date nights, talking over drinks at night, walks together, weekend getaways, loving calls and texts, etc.
Would you want him as your lover, spouse, friend and partner in life?
If so, gotta communicate that to him and see if he will step up more. If not, if your heart is closed off to this possibility with him, well, after 8 years since his betrayal, isnt it time to decide?
[This message edited by DobleTraicion at 3:20 PM, Tuesday, May 27th]