I’m just scared to do the wrong thing.
There's no way to know what path is best for you. The best you - or any of us - can do is make the best guess about the future we can. Making decisions essentially requires putting the fear aside. The sooner you do this, the better for both of you.
The fear probably won't go away until you're well into the solution. You just put it aside and tell yourself, 'You can do difficult things even when you're scared.'
*****
I still love him so
Love is simply not enough.
I feel like I want to but I’m not really committing to R, but I also am struggling and can’t leave. I can imagine so clearly two different life paths for me. But one means I’ll be alone and another means I can have the family unit but it also means to do that I’m tolerating being treated like an option and accepting betrayal and deceit.
You best bet y far is to accept being betrayed and deceived. It's part f your life now. You can't change the past. You can change how you use the past.
You don't have to commit tp R before starting on an R path. Shirley Glass refers to a stage of 'working on the M' for couples who are undecided. That means you work on yourself; your WS works on himself; together you work on your M.
I know that love is a choice and you have to choose to love your partner/spouse everyday.
Yeah. The thing is: it's best to stay out of a primary relationship with someone who doesn't love you the way you want to be loved.
Also - this is crucially important - you can love someone but not be tied to that person. I loved my W up to, through, and after her A - but I'd rather be alone than be with the person she was. If she hadn't shown strong evidence that she was changing after d-day, I think I'd have left, even while loving her.
Disney distorts life. Remember: the little mermaid almost destroyed a civilization because of her hormones. She's a villain, not a hero.
Through the good and bad. Is this the bad that I should keep actively loving him through? How has everyone else managed it?
That's a big part of why I gave my W a chance. She just seemed sick at heart on d-day. I could not bring myself to dump her while she was ill.
But but but.
She came clean on d-day. She took responsibility for her A. She took confrontation after confrontation from our MC, and used that to change the way she approaches life.
I feel embarrassed at myself for thinking "oh but he loves me, he says he won’t do it again, the OW was manipulating him and he couldn’t end it, he’s fully committed to me now"
No need for embarrassment.
I'll say this. My W's ap definitely manipulated her. I won't go into how I know that, but I do. My W never used being manipulated as any sort of excuse, reason, explanation, whatever. Beginning on d-day, she never dodged the fact that she could have said 'no' at any time. If your H is using being manipulated as cover, that's a red flag.
Your H conducted an A for 4 years because all things considered, he thought that was his best course of action.
Now, I (and probably every other BS) believe your H's thinking and feeling is somewhat fucked up. R requires him to change his thinking and feeling. The formula I generally use is: to R, the WS has to change from cheater to good partner.
Telling you he won't cheat again is bullshit. Right now your WS knows he's got a problem because he cheated. That knowledge will fade into the background as time goes on. What will happen the next time he feels unloved?
What is your WS doing to make the necessary changes? What responsibility has he taken? Has he committed to no more lies, ever?
Without change, your WS is a poor bet for R, as is virtually every WS who doesn't change from cheater to good partner.
*****
I know you're in deep pain. I know you want a quick way through the pain. Forcing yourself to make one choice or another will not help.
You're not making a 30 year decision. You're making a 46 year decision. Life expectancy for a 30 year old male in 2020 was almost 46 years; for a female, it's almost 51 years.
You want a good decision. If that takes longer than you'd like it to take, so be it. Stop. Breathe. Don't rush.
Dig deep to find out whether you want to spend another 46 years with this guy the way he is now or not? Figure out what you want from your M after any kids leave. Figure out your requirements for R. Is your current partner a good candidate for long-term R?