Really no surprise for us with the birdseye view of your situation.
Basically, the only surprising factor is how much of a preplanned date this was, considering what she told you the goal was (to discuss things with him).
I’m a bit surprised on one aspect: I did expect her to come home after this tryst and tell you that this was their last ride on the white horse along the sandy beaches, and now she was committed to spending eternity with you – the ogre in the dark castle. Sacrificing herself and her happiness for the family.
SicTransitGloria comments about your contradicting statements is spot-on.
You gave her freedom to choose, and her choice is crystal-clear.
Her actions are the indicator a lot more than her words. She’s constantly telling you she doesn’t know what she wants, yet her actions SHOW clear as daylight she wants to be with OM. You gave her an ultimatum that wasn’t respected, you then gave the Bigger-Speech (albeit a part of it) and she met with OM despite knowing that would check you out. HER ACTIONS ARE TELLING YOU EVERYTHING!!!
Look – if a big tall guy dragged you into an alley and demanded your phone, watch and wallet… it would be a mugging even if he constantly excused himself and thanked you for the donations. Her ACTIONS are telling you EXACTLY what she wants.
Your actions… they are telling her that you want this marriage so badly that the power is in her hands…
There is ONE strategy left that could make it possible for you to remain married to her and keep the house and not "wreck the kids lives" (a claim I don’t agree with in any way…): You could turn a blind eye… You could accept that she has a lover, and she visits him every now and then. Relationships initiated in infidelity seldom last that long, so chances are that before the end of 2024 the OM will have moved on. I HOPE this strategy doesn’t appeal to you, but if your biggest fear is losing this "wife" then it’s possibly your best option. I really stress that I wouldn’t recommend doing this and it’s not something I could do. But if your greatest fear of all is losing her – well… it’s an option.
If not… Well… go read and reread the Bigger Speech and the follow-up advice.
I want to emphasize one thing: My strategy is NOT divorce. I saw it from your first post that your deepest wish was to reclaim your marriage. My plan is 100% based on creating the most likely conditions to enable that. However – that plan requires that at least ONE of you two want out of infidelity, and that at least ONE of you is willing to take the steps to get out of infidelity. Her actions (more than her words) are telling you VERY CLEARLY, she’s not willing to take those steps. Her actions also tell you that she wants to keep her cake and eat it too. Your actions – in order to create the most likely conditions to enable reconciliation – should make it clear to her that she can only keep the cake OR eat it. Not both. The more she nibbles at the slice, or the staler the cake gets – your interest should be waning.
A big part of what I suggest is based on dealing with the fantasy-world of infidelity with reality.
That includes the fantasy’s we BS fall into. Fantasies like our kids’ lives will be wrecked, we will all be destitute and we can’t afford divorce. It also includes the fantasy that the D has to take place NOW, like in the next 24 hours or whatever.
Look – Divorce is a multi-factored process. It’s not as if the beginning and end is the filing or the signing of the final documents. There are parts of the process you can start NOW – even before you contact or decide on a solicitor.
You definitely make it clear you are headed for divorce. After all – you already fired her as your wife and she has told you with her actions she wants the OM. I do address that in the Bigger Speech:
Terminating or relationship and marriage is complex but basically falls into two processes. There is the emotional and the legal. On the legal aspect there are known procedures in place that ensure we are both treated fairly. We need to initiate that process soon to ensure you have the freedom you need to carry on with OM, and to limit our legal commitments to each other since the marriage is ending. I will have a professional handle this from my end, and do not want to discuss it in detail with you.
On the emotional side I need to accept the reality of you having consciously decided to commit to infidelity and knowingly wreck our marriage and family. Our future relationship needs to be as good coparents, but I am starting the process of emotionally detaching from you as much as I can. I have no interest in being friends or in sharing any of your "joy" as you work on your relationship with OM.
For the next days or weeks, we will need to cohabit. I ask – as a favor – that you do NOT have OM in this house and that you be discreet when talking to him or going to him in my presence. But it’s your call – you can be as considerate or as tactless as you decide. But the reality is that people that end marriages also stop living in the same place, so we need to face the future on a basis of reality.
The questions I suggested you ask are practical issues to deal with the simple reality that for the next 30-60 days you two will need to cohabit in some way.
That’s why her claim of getting a couch for the guest-room is empty. It’s fantasy. It’s the "alas… the evil ogre is making me stay in the Dark Castle"… Why spend money on a fold-away couch to sleep on for a month? Why not she take the logical step of simply sleeping at OM house? Is the marital bed a single mattress or two separate? If two then move one. Go get an air-matress. Borrow from a friend. Think solutions rather than think misery.
[This message edited by SI Staff at 12:09 PM, Friday, December 22nd]